
The Top-Down Machine and Bottom-Up Community:
What's Breaking Our World and How We Can Fix It
Summary:
Our world has big problems — from unfair workplaces to struggling families to environmental destruction. These issues all come from the same root: a dominant social system ("the Machine") that teaches us to get ahead by stepping on and exploiting the less powerful and giving in to the more powerful. This system runs on autopilot, making us see life as a win-lose competition.
But there's hope. Good people everywhere are working to fix things in countless ways, including helping the homeless, building stronger communities, running worker-owned companies, and fighting for justice. Right now, these people work separately. This essay suggests they could join forces to create a powerful movement where everyone has a real voice and power is shared.
This movement would fight for basic needs (like living wages and affordable healthcare), strong communities, responsible businesses, and a government that serves the people instead of wealthy elites. It could start with small groups whose members help each other break free from the urge to dominate and the willingness to submit for personal gain. As more groups form and join together, they could build enough power to balance Top-Down Power with Bottom-Up Power.
The choice is ours: keep playing the old game of winners and losers, or build something better together.
The Crisis We Face
Our world is broken. Millions hate going to work, stuck with bosses who treat them like tools instead of humans. Kids go to schools that teach them to compete for grades instead of helping each other learn. Families barely pay their bills while the rich get richer. These and other problems aren’t separate problems — they’re connected.
Society pounds a major message into our heads: life is a game of winners and losers; you must fight to get ahead of others. This poison seeps into everything — our jobs, our schools, our neighborhoods, our families. Even compassion-minded activist organizations compete fiercely for funding. Most of us don't see it; ego-driven competition runs on autopilot; it’s just "the way things are."
Though it's changing to some degree, especially with young people, throughout society our institutions, communities, cultures, and ourselves as individuals reinforce traditional authoritarian patterns — symbolized by the military and monarchies ruled by Kings; superiors give orders and subordinates obey.
In these top-down relationships,
-
Parents tell children what to do "because I said so."
-
One partner dominates households.
-
Teachers tell students what to learn.
-
Employers treat workers like robots.
-
Police are heavy-handed.
-
Doctors give orders.
-
Heads of non-profit housing make the rules.
-
Politicians ignore what voters want.
In Our Social Lives
Contempt poisons our society. Every day, people use cruel labels like "white trash," "welfare queen," and "loser" to make others less than fully human. These aren't just mean words — they're weapons that crush people's spirits. Meanwhile, we worship shallow things like looks, money, and status. Your bank account matters more than your heart. Gaining a higher rank is most important. Money is a way to keep score.
These messages brainwash us daily:
-
“Someone must be in charge”
-
"Look out for number one"
-
"Winners never quit, quitters never win"
-
"Life's a competition — eat or be eaten"
-
"The poor deserve what they get"
-
"Only the strong survive"
These aren't just sayings — they're chains around our minds. They turn us against each other and make us see other humans as enemies to fight or stepping stones to use. Before we know it, we're trapped in this cycle of feeling better or worse than others. We dominate or submit for selfish reasons. People of lower rank are expected to be constantly loyal (submit) to individuals of higher rank or their organization.
In Our Personal Lives
Fear and anger eat away at our souls. When people feel threatened and powerless:
-
They lash out at others they see as "below" them.
-
They suck up to those they see as "above" them.
-
They think their worth comes from their paycheck and the stuff they own.
-
They put down others just to feel better about themselves.
-
They stop seeing other people as human beings.
The human spirit gets twisted. People don’t respect others as equals and don’t really respect themselves. Even people who want to help others often act like they're better than the people they help. Some churches preach that being rich means God loves you more. Some spiritual teachers tell their followers to give up their power and just do what they're told.
In Our Culture
Society’s media tears down our humanity piece by piece:
-
TV and movies make the rich look like heroes and make fun of the poor.
-
Social media turns friendships into a popularity contest.
-
Superficial songwriters ignore social and political issues.
-
Ads tell us we're worthless unless we buy more consumer goods.
-
News outlets rarely examine root causes and treat conflicts like a boxing match.
-
Local TV only covers news briefly; if it bleeds, it leads.
-
Entertainment glorifies violence.
In Business and Work
The economy has become a weapon against human dignity:
-
Big companies block workers' unions with threats and expensive lawyers.
-
Workers get treated like tools that can be thrown away.
-
Companies hide billions in tax money while schools fall apart.
-
Businesses ship jobs overseas, killing whole towns.
-
Corporations maximize profits regardless of the consequences.
In How We Treat Our Planet
We're at war with Earth itself:
-
Ancient forests get cut down in a matter of days.
-
Our oceans drown in plastic waste.
-
Poor neighborhoods choke on pollution.
-
Climate change threatens to make parts of Earth unlivable.
-
Species die out while we argue about whether there's even a problem.
-
Native peoples watch sacred lands get destroyed.
In Politics
Money and power undermine democracy:
-
The super-rich buy elections like they're shopping for cars.
-
Politicians serve the rich and enrich themselves.
-
Wealthy elites monopolize power and spread economic insecurity.
-
We're taught to hate our neighbors while the rich rob us all.
-
Insecure citizens fight each other while the real thieves walk free.
-
True believers care more about defeating the “enemy” than making positive gains.
-
Resentful people hope for a strongman who can fix everything.
-
Nations start wars for profit and power.
-
The MAGA movement undermines democracy.
The Big Picture
These problems are tied together. Society combines our institutions, our cultures, and ourselves as individuals into a single, self-perpetuating, social system: the Top-Down Machine.
No one person or group runs this system. It grinds away even when we replace its managers.
Power flows from the top down. People scramble to climb higher, disrespecting those "below" them, bowing down to those "above" them. People go along to get along.
This Top-Down Machine tells us anyone can "make it" or "get ahead" of others if they work hard enough. That's a lie. People born with advantages have a much easier path, and they make sure their children and friends get these same advantages.
We all keep the Machine running, often without knowing it. Every time we buy cheap clothes made by exploited workers, buy expensive tickets, or vote, we feed it. When we want to be King of the Hill, "lead" others, be in charge, get ahead of and dominate others; we play the game, play the game and we get played. We're pawns. The players change, but the game remains the same. Powerful elites would not be so successful if ordinary people did not collaborate and have domineering and submissive tendencies themselves.
Every nation needs its people to believe in a shared set of core principles. In the United States, this foundation has been the American Dream, as afirmed in the Declaration of Independence with the idea that everyone has the right to "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" This Dream is the belief that anyone, through hard work and determination, can climb the ladder of success, regardless of their background. It embraces individual achievement and self-reliance.
The Trump Administration and its MAGA movement have taken this Dream to the extreme. It's taken the gloves off this mythology and exposed its dark side. It openly idolizes, praises, and promotes domination, power, and greed — with a vengeance, without apology.
Ezra Klein's lengthy August 1, 2025, interview with one of MAGA's leaders, Yoram Hazony, is very revealing. Vice-President J.D. Vance said Hazony "has been quite influential to me.” Hazony is also closely allied with Russell Vought and Stephen Miller, major leaders in the Trump Administration. He's the author of The Virtue of Nationalism and the founder of the pro-MAGA National Conservatism movement, which hosts the annual NatCon convention.
In his interview with Klein, Hazony argues that America needs a more strongly defined Anglo-Saxon "dominant center" that has "a much higher level of compatibility" among its residents, rooted in people who've been here for generations — more cohesive, that is, than we can have with as many immigrants as we have now.
Hazony says that in order to establish this dominant center, the NatCon/MAGA movement must use the power of the government in an intolerant, aggressive manner to rebuild the center — then, and only then, with renewed confidence and strength, America could be tolerant. Or so he claims. Even if you believe he's being honest, this approach hardly seems a reliable way to achieve tolerance. There's no good reason to believe people who gain power with intolerance will become tolerant once they're in control.
Another significant influence on the MAGA movement is Curtis Yarvin, whose monarchist ideas have moved from internet obscurity into mainstream Republican political discourse through his relationships with powerful MAGA politicians and Big Tech leaders who've funded him.
Yarvin advocates replacing American democracy with an authoritarian system and breaking up nations into a "patchwork" of statelets, like Singapore or Dubai, each governed by corporate CEOs selected by secret boards.
During his campaign for Senate, in a 2021 podcast interview, J.D. Vance said:
There's this guy, Curtis Yarvin, who's written about some of these things. A lot of concerns that we should deconstruct the administrative state. We should basically eliminate the administrative state. And I'm sympathetic to that project. But another option is that we should just seize the administrative state for our own purposes.... And then when the courts stop you, stand before the country, like Andrew Jackson did, and say the Chief Justice has made his ruling, now let him enforce it.
In 2021, Michael Anton, who's now State Department Director of Policy Planning, hosted a nearly two-hour podcast with Yarvin during which they discussed why the U.S. needs an "American Caesar" to seize control of the federal government.
Political philosopher Danielle Allen said that the DOGE (Department of Government Efficiency) project is "clearly based on Yarvin's work." Its war on the government has reduced the size of the federal workforce by some 300,000 workers.
Project 2025, the Heritage Foundation's blueprint for a second Trump administration, called for a similar reduction (500,000 employees). At the rate it's going, the Trump administration may achieve this goal, though it will likely fall short of Yarvin's plan to "Retire All Government Employees" (RAGE).
This discrediting and shrinking the federal government gives more power to wealthy corporations and financial institutions. It reduces the government's power to protect the interests of everyday people by rationalizing the me-first, "every man for himself" culture.
Trump says his favorite word is "tariffs," but it may be "dominate," a word he often uses in one form or another. In foreign policy, he openly bullies other nations, especially by using the threat of higher tariffs to get his way, even when it involves interfering with their internal domestic policies. Total domination (loyalty) is clearly the name of his game, internally and externally.
Previous administrations have exercised power-over, as have corporations. But they've been restrained by certain rules and have tried to maximize consensus. Trump, however, is seeking to destroy rules and operate with as few restraints as possible.
What's Working
But it doesn't have to be this way. All around us, good people work to make things better. They help those in need, stand up for what's right, and try to fix what's wrong. Caring people everywhere make things better. They:
-
Help people in need
-
Build stronger communities
-
Stand up against injustice
-
Find ways to work as equals
-
Create ways to share power
These social and political activists include:
-
Workers who own their companies, where everyone gets a voice
-
Volunteers at food banks and homeless shelters
-
Groups creating dignified homes for elderly people
-
Teachers who help students thrive emotionally
-
Neighbors joining forces to solve local problems
Here are some real examples that work:
-
Programs that help older folks stay in their homes while getting good care
-
Communities where people share spaces and make decisions together
-
Small nursing homes that feel like real homes, not warehouses
-
Schools that teach kids not just facts but how to be good people
-
Workers who organize unions
Members of this informal "compassionate humanity community" make a real difference. But right now, they're scattered — like drops of water that could become a mighty river if they came together.
Imagining a Better Future
The problem? These activists usually work alone instead of together, and when they do team up, ego-driven power struggles often tear them apart.
If we could overcome these divisions and join forces, we could build something powerful — where everyone has a voice and power is shared in a multi-issue movement of millions grounded in a shared worldview that reforms society from the bottom up. Some signs are emerging that a movement of this sort might emerge.
Recent developments, for instance, have weakened belief in the traditional American Dream. A majority of Americans no longer believe the American Dream holds true, and younger Americans are affirming values other than financial success and home ownership. Their non-materialistic values that rank more highly include:
-
Feeling personally happy and fulfilled
-
Feeling free to make life decisions
-
Close and meaningful personal relationships.
Moreover, seventy-one percent also affirm "making a difference in others' lives/community."
Many of these people affirm a "new American Dream" that is shifting toward a focus on personal well-being, a more balanced life, happiness, freedom, fulfillment, and meeting the responsibility to make a positive impact on the world. They seek to participate in communities whose members establish meaningful connections and support each other in their lives, as with cohousing and other forms of collaborative living. What if all these activists joined forces?
Just imagine: Many of these like-minded people strengthen the informal compassionate humanity community into a well-organized Bottom-Up Community. In this new social system, everyone has a voice, people hold leaders accountable, and power is shared fairly.
This Bottom-Up Community grows stronger as regular people work together to balance the Top-Down Machine. Members of this community accept that some top-down power is essential, like how we all stop at red lights because we know it keeps others safe. They create fair rules that everyone respects.
Take labor unions as an example: union representatives listen to workers' concerns, work with management to make improvements, and even get seats on company boards where big decisions are made. This example serves as a model for others throughout society.
The Bottom-Up Community doesn’t completely replace the Top-Down Machine; both systems exist side by side and balance each other as each has its strengths.
Social and political activists grow a democratic, member-controlled movement with members who agree on three basic truths:
-
Every person deserves respect, safety, economic security, and a real voice in decisions that affect their life
-
We can help each other become better people by breaking free from the urge to boss others and bow down for personal gain
-
We can make our leaders answer to the people they serve
In this better world:
Everyone Can Meet Their Basic Needs
-
Every person can get a job that pays enough to live on.
-
Everyone can see a doctor when they're sick.
-
People can find homes they can afford.
-
Parents can find good childcare.
-
Workers have unions to fight for their rights.
-
Family farms stay in business.
-
No one lives in fear of becoming homeless.
Communities Are Stronger
-
Police officers know the people they serve.
-
Students help decide what and how they learn.
-
Local farmers' markets keep money in the community.
-
People have time for art, family, and helping others.
-
Anyone who wants help with drugs or mental health can get it.
Work Becomes Fair
-
Companies help their communities, not just chase profits.
-
Workers evaluate supervisors as well as vice versa.
-
Workers help run their companies.
-
Team members give honest feedback to their leaders.
-
More workers own their businesses together.
-
Full-time work means enough pay to live on.
-
Prices stay fair, so everyone can afford what they need.
People Treat Each Other Well
-
Families decide things together.
-
Individuals check in on how everyone's feeling.
-
People really listen to each other.
-
Everyone gets respect.
-
People work out conflicts by talking honestly.
Government Works for Everyone
-
Politicians meet face-to-face with voters regularly.
-
Ordinary citizens study big problems and suggest fixes.
-
America works with other countries as partners, not bullies.
-
Compassionate laws that most Americans support get passed.
-
Money doesn’t control our elections.
The Movement Acts Together
This isn't just talk — it's about building and using real power. The movement:
-
Begins meetings with quiet time — a moment to get grounded and remember why we're fighting. Once a month, in small teams, we have a Holistic Check-in, during which people share their struggles, victories, and efforts to break free from the Top-Down Machine's training.
-
Builds a Purple Alliance that mobilizes millions of Americans to fight for laws most of us already want. Instead of letting politicians divide us, we force them to pass legislation that serves the people, not the powerful. When they resist, we're ready with protests, boycotts, and peaceful civil disobedience.
-
Makes elected officials face the people in monthly Community Dialogues that give everyone a fair chance to speak. Every Representative, Senator, and the President answers for their actions. No more hiding behind speeches — real people, chosen at random, speaking truth to power.
-
It holds National Conventions where Community representatives from across the globe sharpen their strategies and update their goals. This movement isn't run from the top down — it grows and changes based on what members learn in real struggles.
How We Get Started
This fight begins with these steps:
-
Small groups of people say, "Enough." They help each other break free from the Top-Down Machine's conditioning, which inflames the urge to dominate others and bow down to power for personal gain. In this way, they overcome the ego-driven power trips that weaken so many groups. They stand together, grow together, and fight for change together. Most importantly, they prove another way is possible.
-
These groups include groups within existing organizations, such as social action committees, and book clubs, as well as individuals who form a peer support group. They dedicate themselves to countering the Top-Down Machine and identify with the Bottom-up Community.
-
Word spreads. The initial groups form a mutual support network. Others see these groups working together with mutual respect and shared power — no bosses, no followers, just equals fighting for change. More groups form. The spark catches fire.
-
These groups join forces, bringing together fighters and dreamers from every corner of their country. They hold a national convention that launches something new: not just another organization, but a movement to change the world. Eventually, they convene a global convention.
This might sound like a dream.It could be. But dreams have power. Even talking about these ideas plants seeds in people's minds. Some seeds might grow into small changes — a fairer workplace here, a stronger community there. Or they might burst into something bigger — a movement powerful enough to shake the Top-Down Machine to its core and compel it to make structural changes that spread democracy throughout society.
We don't know exactly what will happen. The Top-Down Machine won't give up power easily. But we know this: every time someone stands up instead of backing down, every time people join hands instead of turning against each other, every time we choose solidarity over selfishness — we get one step closer to the world we need.
The choice is ours. We can stay trapped in the Top-Down Machine's game of domination and submission for personal gain, or we can start building something new — something human, something fair, something worth fighting for: a Bottom-Up Community that balances the Top-Down Machine..
What side are you on?